• Shopware Gold Partner & Shopify Partner

Chapter 9

Average order value: The quiet profit lever

Table of contents

Two stores with identical traffic and an identical conversion rate can be very differently profitable. The difference lies in a number that sits unnoticed between revenue and conversion rate in many reports: the average order value.

What order value measures

Net revenue divided by the number of orders. Order value helps decide how heavily shipping, packaging and fixed payment fees weigh on your margin – precisely where most other levers fail: the cost per order.

Every order causes costs that hardly depend on its size. Packaging costs the same at €50 as at €150. The parcel costs about the same, picking takes about as long, and the payment provider's fixed fee is charged once. The higher the order value, the smaller the share of these costs in revenue.

The calculation

A store with 30,000 sessions, a 2 percent conversion rate and an €85 order value: 600 orders, €51,000 net revenue. Then it manages to raise the order value to €95, up 11.8 percent. Traffic, conversion rate and ad budget stay the same.

Item

Before (€85)

After (€95)

Difference

Net revenue

€51,000

€57,000

+€6,000

Cost of goods sold (45%)

€22,950

€25,650

+€2,700

Shipping (per parcel)

€2,400

€2,400

€0

Packaging (per parcel)

€720

€720

€0

Fixed payment fee

€210

€210

€0

Variable payment fee (1.9%)

€969

€1,083

+€114

Ad spend

€5,100

€5,100

€0

Contribution margin

€18,651

€21,837

+€3,186

The €6,000 of additional revenue generates €3,186 of additional contribution margin. 53 percent of the additional revenue goes straight into contribution margin, and contribution margin rises by 17 percent. For comparison: had the same store increased revenue by €6,000 through more advertising, shipping, packaging and additional ad spend would have been incurred on top of cost of goods.

(Simplification: shipping stays the same as long as parcels do not get much heavier.)

Benchmarks

Industry

Typical order value (incl. VAT)

Beauty and supplements

€35 to €75

Fashion and accessories

€65 to €150

Sports and outdoor

€80 to €220

Electronics and technology

€120 to €400

Furniture and home

€180 to €600

Luxury and jewelry

€250 to €1,500

B2B stores

€200 to €5,000

Five levers for bigger, more profitable orders

  • Free shipping above a threshold: 15 to 25 percent above your current order value is a sensible starting point for a test. Too low gives away margin, too high gets ignored. Important: use the same tax basis – in a B2C store the threshold is shown including VAT, but the calculation is net.

  • Complementary products: on the product page, in the cart and on the thank-you page – relevant, not random. On the thank-you page it is particularly worthwhile if the additional product is added to the existing order. If a separate order is created, shipping, packaging and fixed payment costs are incurred again.

  • Bundles: several products at a package price with a noticeable but limited saving.

  • Volume tiers: graduated discounts from a certain quantity, especially for consumables.

  • The higher-value variant: make the premium variant visible on the product page, with clear added value.

Each of these levers costs margin if it is set up incorrectly. So check contribution margin per order and total contribution margin with comparable traffic. A higher order value must not be bought with too many lost orders.

The math behind "free shipping"

To get free shipping, a customer adds €20 net to the cart. At a 40 percent contribution margin, that creates €8 of additional contribution margin. At the same time, the €4.90 shipping contribution the customer would otherwise have paid disappears. That leaves €3.10. The basket has grown by €20, the return by just over three euros. The threshold is still worth it – but only if it is calculated from margin and shipping costs and measured against the result.

When order value rises for the wrong reasons

If your order value only rises because cheap products are sold out or small orders stay away altogether, that is not a sales success. So always also look at items per order, number of orders and product mix.

The trap in the channel view

Order value differs depending on where buyers come from, often considerably. Buyers from social advertising often place smaller orders than buyers who come directly or via email. A channel with a good ROAS can therefore still be a weak channel if its orders are small and the cost per order eats up the contribution margin.

How category copy written as buying advice and guides make choosing easier for buyers is explained on the page content for online stores.

What you can check today

  1. Do you know your order value and its trend over the last 24 months?

  2. Do you know your order value split by new and returning customers and by channel?

  3. Is your free shipping threshold 15 to 25 percent above your current order value?

  4. Do you know how many items your customers buy per order on average?

  5. Are there complementary products on the product page, in the cart and on the thank-you page?

  6. Is the effect of discounts and bundles measured by contribution margin per order?

Frequently asked questions

Net revenue divided by the number of orders. For steering, the net value after discounts is recommended.

Because the cost per order stays largely the same. In the worked example, an order value just under 12 percent higher increases contribution margin by 17 percent.

As a starting point for a test, about 15 to 25 percent above the current order value, on the same tax basis. Then watch the effect on order value, conversion rate and contribution margin.

A free shipping threshold and suitable complementary products are the best first tests. Which measure works better for you is not shown by order value but by your additional contribution margin.

Not necessarily. What matters is whether total contribution margin rises. Smaller but more numerous orders can pay off if the cost per order is under control.