Chapter 11
From gross profit to contribution margin: What your store really keeps
Table of contents
The monthly management accounts of a fashion store show a gross margin of 58 percent. The managing director shows this number to the bank. Work through all the costs per order and a different picture emerges: returns cost 12 percentage points, shipping 7, payment fees 3.5, packaging and fulfillment 6. Of the supposed 58 percent, only 29.5 percent contribution margin is left before advertising.
Around half of the margin is gone before the first euro of advertising has been paid. And it is exactly this number that decides whether a managing director increases or cuts the ad budget, expands or consolidates.
What the wrong margin does in the ad account
Anyone calculating with a 58 percent margin arrives at a break-even ROAS of 1.72. With the real 29.5 percent contribution margin, the threshold is 3.39. A ROAS of 3 then looks comfortably profitable – and is in fact already producing a negative contribution margin after advertising. Every additional advertising euro increases the loss, while the report announces success.
Why management accounts are not enough to steer a store
Your management accounts show your company's result, and for that they are a good steering tool. For decisions about products, channels and ad budgets, however, they lack the necessary detail. For that, you also need a contribution margin calculation. Two effects distort the picture in the management accounts in particular:
Costs that are not in gross profit. Gross profit is revenue minus cost of goods sold. All costs incurred per order appear further down in the accounts or not separately at all:
shipping costs the store pays itself
payment fees, which vary greatly depending on the payment method
the costs of returns: return shipping, inspection, refurbishment, loss of value and goods that cannot be resold
packaging and fulfillment
goodwill payments not offset against revenue
Discounts, vouchers and refunded purchase prices are usually already deducted from net revenue – they are not deducted a second time. The additional costs of a return reduce contribution margin but are not fully visible in gross profit.
Purchases instead of cost of goods sold. In many monthly management accounts, the material expense shown is the month's purchases, not the cost of the goods actually sold. Anyone who buys stock for the Christmas season in October sees a poor margin in October and a brilliant one in December. Both are wrong. Only with the change in inventory, i.e. a stock count or properly maintained inventory management, does the real gross profit emerge.
Depending on the industry, the real contribution margin before advertising is therefore 5 to 40 percentage points below the gross margin in the management accounts.
The three margin levels
Gross profit: net revenue minus cost of goods sold.
Contribution margin I: gross profit minus all variable costs per order (shipping, packaging, fulfillment, payment fees, return costs).
The starting point is always net revenue after discounts, credit notes and refunds.
Contribution margin II: contribution margin I minus ad spend. This is the money left over to cover your fixed costs.
Benchmarks
Industry | Gross margin | Contribution margin I | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
Beauty and supplements | 65 to 80% | 45 to 60% | 15 to 25 pp |
Fashion and accessories | 55 to 65% | 20 to 30% | 30 to 40 pp |
Sports and outdoor | 40 to 55% | 20 to 35% | 15 to 25 pp |
Electronics and technology | 18 to 30% | 8 to 18% | 8 to 14 pp |
Furniture and home | 40 to 55% | 20 to 32% | 18 to 25 pp |
Luxury and jewelry | 45 to 65% | 30 to 50% | 12 to 18 pp |
B2B stores | 25 to 45% | 18 to 38% | 5 to 10 pp |
What returns really cost
A return costs a mid-sized fashion store roughly €10 to €20, depending on the process – for return shipping, inspection, refurbishment and the loss of value of the goods. An example: €4 million in revenue, an €80 order value, so 50,000 orders. At a 25 percent return rate, that is 12,500 returns. At €15 per return, this adds up to around €190,000 in return costs per year – on top of the refunded purchase price. (Revenue and order value here on the same basis, before refunds.)
Important for a clean calculation: a resellable return is not a complete loss of goods. Revenue is corrected, and the goods go back into stock. The margin is burdened by return transport, handling and the actual loss of value. And one type of cost is almost always forgotten: with many providers, you do not get the original payment fee back, or only part of it. You pay the fee for revenue that no longer exists.
What payment methods cost
Payment method | Typical variable fee | Typical fixed fee |
|---|---|---|
Credit card | 1.4 to 2.5% | €0.10 to €0.35 |
PayPal | 2.5 to 3.5% | €0.35 to €0.39 |
Invoice / installments (e.g. Klarna) | 2.5 to 4.5% | €0.20 to €0.45 |
SEPA direct debit via a provider | 0 to 1.0% (sometimes a fixed fee only) | €0.20 to €0.40 |
Prepayment / bank transfer | 0% | €0 |
Apple Pay / Google Pay | as the stored card | as the stored card |
The values are typical ranges and depend heavily on contract and volume. Depending on the store, the payment method mix decides one to three percentage points of contribution margin. Switching off payment methods is still rarely the solution, because missing payment methods cost orders (see Chapter 10). Instead, check your actual fees per payment method and use your transaction volume to negotiate better terms.
What you can check today
Do you know your contribution margin I – or only the gross profit from your management accounts?
Do your monthly management accounts show cost of goods sold including the change in inventory, or only purchases?
Do you know your average cost per return?
Do you know how your payment fees are distributed across the individual payment methods?
Do you know how much you pay on top for shipping per order?
Do you know your contribution margin per product category?
Frequently asked questions
Gross profit is revenue minus cost of goods sold. Contribution margin I also deducts all variable costs per order. For steering an online store, contribution margin is the more meaningful number.
Because they show the company's result, not the contribution margin of individual orders, products and channels. Costs per order are not in gross profit, and monthly figures often show purchases instead of cost of goods sold.
Net revenue after discounts minus cost of goods sold minus all variable costs per order. These include shipping, packaging, fulfillment, payment fees and return costs. Discounts already included in net revenue are not deducted again.
In mid-sized fashion stores, roughly €10 to €20 per return. Return shipping, inspection, refurbishment and loss of value combined, on top of the refunded purchase price.
Yes, if volume and fixed costs fit. But then there is little room for advertising: the break-even ROAS is almost 7.
)