• Shopware Gold Partner & Shopify Partner

Chapter 4

Why ROAS lies and POAS tells the truth

Table of contents

Every month, managing directors sit in front of a report in which one number looks like success and still says nothing about whether the store is making money. That number is called ROAS. It is presented in every ad meeting, and it misleads more decision-makers than any other metric in e-commerce.

What ROAS measures and what it does not

Return on ad spend is a simple formula: ad revenue divided by ad spend. €220,000 in net revenue on €20,000 of ad spend gives a ROAS of 11.

What is missing from this number: cost of goods sold, shipping costs after the customer's contribution, the fees for PayPal, Klarna and credit cards, returns, discounts and vouchers, packaging and fulfillment. Classic ROAS takes none of these costs into account. With additional cart and cost data, Google Ads can report gross profit (Chapter 13). But even then, shipping, fees and returns are missing for your full contribution margin.

ROAS measures revenue efficiency. On its own, it does not show whether your advertising makes money. For the question a managing director cares about – am I making money with this ad channel? – it is not enough.

The calculation no dashboard shows

A garden and DIY store with a solid margin and a low return rate. Monthly ad revenue €220,000, ad spend €20,000, ROAS 11. All revenue figures exclude VAT but are before discounts and vouchers, which are deducted separately. (If your revenue figure already includes discounts, do not deduct them again.)

Item

Share

Amount

Revenue (net, before discounts)

100.0%

€220,000

Cost of goods sold

45.0%

€99,000

Packaging and fulfillment

3.5%

€7,700

Shipping after customer contribution

5.0%

€11,000

Payment fees

2.0%

€4,400

Returns (handling, loss of value)

3.5%

€7,700

Discounts, vouchers, goodwill

2.5%

€5,500

Contribution margin I (before advertising)

38.5%

€84,700

Ad spend

9.1%

€20,000

Contribution margin II (after advertising)

29.4%

€64,700

ROAS 11 – POAS 4.24.

POAS, profit on ad spend, measures contribution margin per advertising euro: contribution margin I divided by ad spend. Here, every advertising euro brings in €4.24 of contribution margin; after deducting the euro itself, €3.24 is left. A healthy business, and at the same time a sign that more budget could make sense.

The same ROAS, a completely different truth

Now the same ROAS of 11 in an electronics store. High cost of goods, fierce price competition, little room to maneuver:

Item

Share

Amount

Revenue (net, before discounts)

100.0%

€220,000

Cost of goods sold

74.0%

€162,800

Packaging and fulfillment

2.0%

€4,400

Shipping after customer contribution

3.0%

€6,600

Payment fees

1.8%

€3,960

Returns

3.0%

€6,600

Discounts and price reductions

2.5%

€5,500

Contribution margin I

13.7%

€30,140

Ad spend

9.1%

€20,000

Contribution margin II

4.6%

€10,140

ROAS 11 – POAS 1.51.

Same ROAS, same budget, same revenue. But here only 51 cents of every advertising euro is left instead of €3.24.

Now turn the screw one more time: the same electronics store achieves a ROAS of 6. Sounds decent – but with this cost structure it is not enough. At €220,000 revenue, that means €36,667 of ad spend. Contribution margin I stays at €30,140. Result: minus €6,527 contribution margin II, POAS 0.82. Every advertising euro destroys 18 cents. And nobody in the room sees it as long as everyone is looking at ROAS.

When even a ROAS of 11 costs money

In particularly low-margin assortments, such as smartphones, game consoles or branded goods in a price war, the contribution margin before advertising is often only 8 percent. Then €220,000 of revenue leaves €17,600 of contribution margin. With €20,000 of ad spend, that means: ROAS 11 – and a €2,400 loss, before a single euro of rent or salary has been paid. The break-even ROAS here is 12.5.

Anyone who steers both assortments by the same target ROAS treats commercially completely different businesses the same. That is exactly why your advertising needs the margins of the products actually sold.

Your break-even ROAS

The single most important number to take away from this chapter: break-even ROAS = 1 ÷ contribution margin before advertising.

  • Garden store: 1 ÷ 0.385 = 2.6

  • Electronics store: 1 ÷ 0.137 = 7.3

Above this threshold, a positive contribution margin after advertising remains. Your fixed costs and your profit have to be funded from it – so the break-even ROAS is the floor, not the target. Two stores, two completely different thresholds. A universal "good ROAS" does not exist.

Why POAS is not the whole truth either

POAS is calculated on the revenue the ad platform attributes to itself. That includes purchases that would have happened without the ad: brand searches, returning customers, buyers who brush past an ad shortly before buying.

The commercially cleanest metric is therefore incremental POAS = additional contribution margin before advertising ÷ ad spend used to generate it. It only counts the contribution margin that would not have happened without the advertising. If, in the electronics example, 70 percent of the attributed contribution margin is truly additional, the POAS of 1.51 becomes an incremental POAS of about 1.05. The advertising then just about pays for itself. How high the additional share is in your store can only be determined with tests (see Chapter 2).

Why this calculation is missing from many reports

Because the data sits in systems that do not talk to each other. Revenue is in the store, cost of goods in inventory management, returns in logistics, fees in accounting, ad spend at Google, Meta and Microsoft. Only when these pieces come together does the number a managing director needs emerge: contribution margin after all variable costs, per channel and over time.

How to not only measure POAS but steer your campaigns by it is shown in Chapter 13.

How arboro aligns Google Ads campaigns with contribution margin instead of revenue is explained on the page Google Ads for Shopware and Shopify.

What you can check today

  1. Do you know your contribution margin before advertising as one current number – after cost of goods, shipping, fees, returns and discounts?

  2. Calculate your break-even ROAS: 1 divided by that margin. With the Google Ads Profit Calculator it takes five minutes.

  3. Does your monthly report show POAS or contribution margin per ad channel next to ROAS?

  4. Would your marketing team or agency know immediately at which ROAS your store slips into the loss zone?

  5. Is ROAS in your reporting calculated on net or gross revenue? At 19 percent VAT, as in Germany, a gross ROAS of 11 is only a net ROAS of 9.24.

Frequently asked questions

ROAS measures revenue per advertising euro, POAS measures contribution margin per advertising euro. POAS deducts cost of goods, shipping, fees, returns and discounts and shows what is really left.

Your margin determines the break-even point, your goals determine the rest. With a 40 percent contribution margin, the break-even ROAS is 2.5; with 14 percent, it is above 7. Which ROAS above that is good for you also depends on fixed costs, growth target and customer value.

Break-even ROAS = 1 ÷ contribution margin before advertising. With a 30 percent margin, it is 3.33. Below that, every advertising euro costs more than it brings in.

From a POAS above 1.0. Then every advertising euro brings in more contribution margin than it costs. How much headroom you need above that depends on your fixed costs and your goals.

On net revenue. VAT does not belong to you. Anyone who calculates with gross figures overestimates ROAS by the tax rate: at 19 percent VAT, a gross ROAS of 11 corresponds to a net ROAS of 9.24.

Usually not. It requires purchase prices and cost data that are not available in the ad platforms by default. Ask for it specifically.