Chapter 7
New and returning customer share: Where your growth really comes from
Table of contents
A beauty store presents strong figures to its investor: 34 percent more revenue, ad budget raised from €420,000 to €680,000, ROAS stable. Then the managing director has a number calculated that appears in no report: of 44,000 newly acquired customers, only 6,200 ordered a second time within twelve months of their first purchase – 14 percent. The store was an expensive machine that wins customers and loses almost all of them again. Its growth depended entirely on ever more acquisition.
Two numbers, two perspectives
New and returning customer shares can be calculated by customers, by orders or by revenue. In this chapter, we compare two of them:
Share of first orders: what share of all orders in a month is a customer's first order?
Returning customer revenue share: what share of revenue comes from repeat orders by customers who have already ordered at least once?
The two numbers can differ considerably. An example: 65 percent of orders are first orders, but 45 percent of revenue comes from returning customers. Returning customers deliver 35 percent of orders and 45 percent of revenue here – their average order value is therefore around 52 percent higher than that of first-time buyers. For steering, the revenue share matters most, because it shows how much of your business holds up without new acquisition.
Both numbers come from the store backend, i.e. level 1 of the data source pyramid. This requires clean customer recognition, including for guest orders, for example via the email address.
Why this number rarely appears in the ad report
Ad reports are measured by ROAS and attributed revenue. Whether the acquired customers come back plays no role in them. Yet that is exactly the difference between two stores with the same ROAS: one acquires customers who order almost three times on average. The other acquires customers who buy exactly once. The first is building a customer base; the second is buying revenue on loan.
Three orders are only better than one, however, if more contribution margin remains after discounts, returns and renewed ad spend. So judge your new customer sources by the contribution margin of their customers after six or twelve months – not by the first basket.
Benchmarks
Store type | Returning customer revenue share (healthy) | Weak |
|---|---|---|
Consumables (beauty, food, supplements) | 50 to 70% | below 35% |
Fashion and accessories | 35 to 55% | below 25% |
Furniture and home | 15 to 30% | below 10% |
Electronics and technology | 20 to 35% | below 15% |
B2B stores (wholesale, industry) | 65 to 85% | below 50% |
Hobby, sports, niches | 40 to 60% | below 25% |
The four patterns
Pattern 1 – Growth without a growing customer base: a high new customer rate, rising total revenue, but stagnating returning customer revenue. All growth has to be bought expensively.
Pattern 2 – Silent erosion: a seemingly stable returning customer share carried only by an old group of loyal customers. New customers do not stay. This collapses when the old group thins out.
Pattern 3 – Illusory loyalty: the returning customer share rises – and everyone is pleased. An example: returning customer revenue stays at €200,000, new customer revenue falls from €200,000 to €100,000. The returning customer share rises from 50 to 67 percent, while total revenue falls by 25 percent. The ratio looks better, the business shrinks. That is why the absolute revenue of both groups always belongs next to every ratio.
Pattern 4 – Building up: rising returning customer revenue with stable new customer acquisition, systematic email activation, high repeat purchase rates even among new customer groups.
Whether you are in pattern 2 or 4 can only be shown by a cohort analysis. The key question is: How many of the customers you acquired in January ordered again within 90 days – and what does the same figure look like for the February and March customers? More on this in Chapter 14.
What you can check today
Do you know your returning customer revenue share for the last twelve months – and the absolute revenue of new and returning customers behind it?
Do you know how these numbers have developed over the last three years?
How many of your new customers order again within twelve months of their first purchase?
Do you know the contribution margin per new customer after six or twelve months, broken down by acquisition channel?
Have you seen a cohort analysis in the last twelve months?
Frequently asked questions
Both can be calculated by customers, orders or revenue – what matters is stating the basis. Because returning customers often have a higher order value, their revenue share is usually higher than their share of orders.
That depends heavily on the industry. For furniture or electronics, 20 to 30 percent is healthy; for consumables and in B2B, 50 to 85 percent.
No. It can also rise because new customer acquisition collapses. So always look at the absolute revenue of new and returning customers.
From the store backend. Every order there is assigned to a customer. It is important to merge guest orders with existing customers via the email address.
Tracking a group of new customers from the same period over time. It shows whether newly acquired customers buy again more or less often than earlier customer groups.
Email can remind first-time buyers of their next purchase at the right moment – for example when a consumable is running out. Without click costs, to customers who already know your store.
)