• Shopware Gold Partner & Shopify Partner

Chapter 14

Repeat purchase rate: The capital most people overlook

Table of contents

The second order shows whether expensively acquired attention turns into a customer relationship. Anyone who orders a second time moves from one-time buyer to a customer who knows your assortment. And every further order brings you closer to recovering your acquisition costs – whether a customer is already making money is shown by their cumulative contribution margin relative to CAC.

Repeat purchase rate and returning customer share

The returning customer share from Chapter 7 is a snapshot: how much revenue comes from returning customers today? The repeat purchase rate asks dynamically: What becomes of the customers we acquired in a particular month? It measures the quality of your new customer acquisition and your customer retention.

Both numbers come directly from the store backend, i.e. from real orders with customer assignment.

How it is calculated: 90-day repeat purchase rate = first-time buyers with at least one further order within 90 days ÷ all first-time buyers in the group under review × 100. Of 1,000 first-time buyers, 250 order again: repeat purchase rate 25 percent. Each customer counts once, however often they reorder.

The three relevant time windows

  • 30 days: how many first-time buyers order again within a month? Important for consumables.

  • 90 days: the most important strategic window for most assortments.

  • 365 days: how many first-time buyers order at least once more in their first year?

Why the second order changes so much

With every order, the probability of the next one rises. The biggest hurdle is the step from the first to the second purchase. Making this step systematically easier improves customer value, CAC payback (Chapter 12) and often order value and return rate too, because repeat buyers know your assortment and your sizes.

Benchmarks

Share of first-time buyers who order again within the period:

Industry

30 days

90 days

365 days

Supplements and consumables

8 to 15%

20 to 35%

35 to 55%

Beauty and personal care

5 to 10%

15 to 25%

30 to 45%

Fashion and accessories

3 to 6%

8 to 15%

20 to 35%

Sports and outdoor

2 to 5%

6 to 12%

15 to 30%

Electronics and technology

1 to 3%

3 to 8%

10 to 20%

Furniture and home

below 1%

1 to 4%

5 to 12%

B2B stores

15 to 30%

30 to 50%

50 to 75%

Luxury and jewelry

1 to 3%

3 to 8%

10 to 20%

These values are practical experience and vary greatly by assortment, price level and purchase cycle. Comparing your own cohorts over time is the most meaningful.

Five levers for the second purchase

  • A welcome series after the first purchase: thank you, usage tips, suitable additions, a reason for the second purchase.

  • Replenishment reminders for consumables: timed to the actual consumption cycle of your products.

  • A rewards program: points, loyalty prices or exclusive access – if it suits the assortment.

  • Personal follow-up: review request, service tip, recommendation based on the first purchase.

  • A smooth first experience: delivery time, packaging, returns process. The best email cannot rescue a disappointing first purchase.

The cohort analysis

All customers who ordered for the first time in January form the January cohort. The analysis tracks how many of them bought again after 30, 90 and 365 days. Comparing cohorts shows whether your customer retention is getting better or worse – and whether a new ad campaign is winning customers who buy again after the introductory offer.

For the comparison to be fair, one rule applies: compare each group after the same time since the first purchase. A complete 90-day rate is only fixed once the last first-time buyer in the group has had 90 days. Otherwise, younger cohorts automatically look worse.

What a better repeat rate is worth

If the 90-day repeat purchase rate among 1,000 first-time buyers rises from 25 to 35 percent, you gain 100 additional repeat buyers. With one additional order each at €18.70 contribution margin, this creates €1,870 of additional contribution margin – per 1,000 new customers, before the costs of activation. With 14,000 new customers a year, as in the example from Chapter 12, that is more than €26,000, without buying a single additional new customer. And every one of these orders shortens the time until the acquisition has paid for itself.

The trap in measuring success

A repeat purchase email is happily credited with revenue that loyal customers would have generated anyway. Whether the series really brings additional orders can only be shown by a control group that does not receive it. It is the same idea as with advertising: attributed is not the same as additional.

How to reach existing customers again through newsletters and guides is explained on the page content for online stores.

What you can check today

  1. Do you know your 90-day repeat purchase rate?

  2. Do you know how this number has developed over the last 24 months?

  3. Do you know the average time between first and second order?

  4. Is there an automated welcome series after the first purchase?

  5. Do you know the repeat purchase rate per acquisition channel?

  6. Is there a target value for the 90-day repeat purchase rate?

Frequently asked questions

The share of first-time buyers who order again within a certain period. Time windows of 30, 90 and 365 days are common.

The returning customer share is a snapshot of revenue; the repeat purchase rate tracks groups of new customers over time. It shows whether new customers stay.

That depends heavily on the purchase cycle. For furniture, 5 to 12 percent in the first year is normal; for consumables, 35 to 55 percent; in B2B often more.

With a welcome series, replenishment reminders, a suitable rewards program and a smooth first purchase experience.

Shortly before your typical customers would order again on their own. A good starting point is the typical time to second purchase from your store backend – split by first product and purchase quantity.